The Cake Shop

Custom cakes, cupcakes, & cookies for your next special event! 

Everything is made just for you with quality ingredients and lots of love!

Dates fill up quickly! Typical notice is 3 weeks or more.

Take a look and give us a call to make your custom order today! 414.446.8057

-Photo slideshow below and even more cakes can be seen on our Facebook page-

Pick a Cake:Pick a Filling:Pick a Topping:    
ChocolateVanilla ButtercreamVanilla Buttercream
YellowChocolate ButtercreamChocolate Buttercream  
WhiteStrawberry ButtercreamStrawberry Buttercream    
Red VelvetCaramel ButtercreamCaramel Buttercream
LemonNutella ButtercreamNutella Buttercream
StrawberryPeanut Butter ButtercreamPeanut Butter Buttercream     
Cookies-n-CreamCookies-n-Cream Buttercream           Cream Cheese Frosting
CarrotCream Cheese FrostingRaspberry Cream Cheese
Gluten-Free YellowLemon CurdChocolate Ganache
Gluten-Free Chocolate

Fresh Fruit Filling

(strawberry, raspberry, blueberry, blackberry)

White Chocolate Ganache
Most flavors available as Vegan  

Prices include one flavor and one filling with simple decorations for a buttercream design that may include small 2D fondant decorations (flowers, dots, animal prints, etc.).  PRICES WILL INCREASE WITH LEVEL OF DIFFICULTY, such as, more detailed or 3D fondant designs and/or shaped cakes.  All sizes below indicate two layers of cake (approximately 4-inches tall), unless otherwise noted.  Serving sizes are based on 2" x 2" pieces.   DELIVERY FEE = Free within a 5 mile radius of I-43 & Good Hope Rd., $1.50 per mile beyond that (one-way only).  You are, of course, welcomed to pick your cake up!

Party Cakes (Single Tier Cakes)

Round 6-inch6-8$28$33
Round 8-inch12-14$43$51
Round 10-inch16-21$63$75
Round 12-inch25-28$83 $100

Square 6-inch7-9$30$34
Square 8-inch12-16$51$58
Square 10-inch20-25$78$89
Square 12-inch31-36$111$127

1/4 sheet cake - one layer, no filling, 20-25 servings = $40 Buttercream or $48 Fondant

1/2 sheet cake - one layer, no filling, 50-54 servings = $77 Buttercream or $88 Fondant

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake - one layer, no filling, 12" round x 1.5" thick, 15-20 servings = $28

Tiered Cakes

Round 6" + 8"18-22$78$89
Round 8" + 10"28-35$112135
Round 6" + 8" + 10"34-43$143$167

Square 6" + 8"19-25$88$100
Square 8" + 10"32-41$136$155
Square 6" + 8" + 10"39-50$168$192

Cupcakes & Cookies

Our cupcakes are the same size you would make at home, not mini and not jumbo.  Mini and Jumbo are available with a price adjustment.

Our cookies are a 3"-4" sugar cookie with royal icing and come in many shapes and designs to fit your event theme.

Orders are 'by the dozen' only.

Cupcake FlavorsSimple DesignDetailed DesignFondant Design
same as above$20 a dozen$25 a dozen$30 a dozen/cupcakes only